U.S. Spot Bitcoin ETFs Reported $2.89B in November Outflows, but Dates Need Clarification
Figures attributed to Farside Investors show nearly $2.89 billion in net withdrawals from U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs through Nov. 18. BlackRock’s IBIT accounted for about 83% of the reported total, but date inconsistencies make the daily breakdown difficult to verify.
- Reported net outflows: $2.8855 billion through Nov. 18.
- Largest fund outflows: Nearly $2.40 billion from BlackRock’s IBIT.
- Key caveat: The cited tally does not name a year and labels Nov. 16 as a trading session.
- What flows show: Fund-level net activity, not individual investors’ purchase prices or motives.
Large withdrawals, concentrated in IBIT
Daily figures attributed to Farside Investors show that U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs recorded $2.8855 billion in net withdrawals over the first 13 U.S. trading sessions of November, through Nov. 18. BlackRock’s iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF (IBIT) accounted for nearly $2.40 billion, or about 83% of the total.
The largest reported single-day withdrawal was $430.2 million on Nov. 5. Another $411.9 million left the funds on Nov. 6, bringing the two-session total to $842.1 million. That day, Fidelity’s FBTC received $42.8 million even as $403 million flowed out of IBIT.
The figures also show $306.5 million in net withdrawals across seven funds on Nov. 18. IBIT lost $148.7 million, Fidelity’s fund lost $69.3 million, and Bitwise’s BITB lost $36.6 million. Together, the three funds accounted for more than four-fifths of that day’s reported outflows.
The dates are a problem: the tally does not specify a year, and it lists Nov. 16 as a trading session. Nov. 16 fell on a weekend in both 2024 and 2025, the November periods since U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs began trading. Without clarification, the daily figures cannot be matched confidently to a calendar. Treat the aggregate as a reported total, not a fully reconciled daily series.
What ETF outflows measure, and what they don’t
ETF shares typically trade between investors on an exchange. When one shareholder sells and another buys, the fund does not necessarily have to sell Bitcoin. Its share supply and holdings adjust through large-block creations and redemptions handled by authorized participants.
That makes net outflows useful, but limited. They show that withdrawals exceeded inflows at the fund level. They do not reveal how many individual shareholders sold, whether they sold at a profit, or how much Bitcoin the funds sold to meet redemptions.
Cost-basis estimates are not shareholder purchase records
On Nov. 19, Bitfinex warned that ETF investors with large losses might use a price recovery to reduce their positions. Some holders could respond that way, but the warning is not evidence that they are likely to sell. Bitfinex said several consecutive sessions of net inflows would be a stronger sign that demand was returning.
The nearly 25% loss estimate cited alongside that warning needs context. It comes from a Glassnode measure that estimates Bitcoin’s price on days when ETFs recorded net deposits, weighted by the size of those deposits. Days with larger net deposits count more. Outflow days do not change the average.
This is a fund-flow cost-basis estimate, not a record of what individual ETF shareholders paid. Shares can trade at different prices. And the price of Bitcoin on a day a fund receives net deposits cannot establish every shareholder’s entry price or current gain or loss.
Bitfinex also looked at a narrower window: flows from Aug. 17 to Sept. 25 had an estimated average entry price of $80, 070. That period accounted for $5.76 billion of the $6.36 billion in net inflows during the third quarter. At the $64, 952 Bitcoin close used in that calculation, those flows were down about 19%. This is a separate estimate for a specific period, not a contradiction of the broader figure.
The price references lack enough timing detail for a precise comparison. The figures put Bitcoin around $63, 800 on a Thursday, after an intraday dip near $62, 100 the previous day, and say it had fallen about 11% from its Nov. 12 close over the preceding week. Without a year and exact dates for the price snapshots, those figures cannot be reliably matched to the ETF-flow tally.
One day of inflows is not a trend
The tally says the funds recorded net inflows on only two of the first 13 November sessions: $74.6 million on Nov. 4 and $7.9 million on Nov. 16. It says the latter ended a seven-session outflow streak. IBIT received $76.5 million, while withdrawals from other funds absorbed most of the demand. The tally then reports $546.4 million in combined withdrawals over the next two sessions. The Nov. 16 date is one of the entries that needs clarification.
In separate October research, Glassnode analyst Frederik Theissen noted that U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs received about $653 million on Oct. 19, their largest intake since Sept. 22, after a week of net withdrawals. Trading volume across the funds that day was below its typical level over the previous year, and their 30-day average volume was less than a quarter of its level a year earlier. The comparison is a reminder that a large inflow says less without context about trading activity. By itself, it does not establish a lasting shift in demand.
Key questions about Bitcoin ETF outflows
-
How much did U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs reportedly lose through Nov. 18?
The cited tally reports $2.8855 billion in net withdrawals. It does not specify a year, and its Nov. 16 entry does not match a U.S. trading session in 2024 or 2025.
-
Which fund had the largest reported outflows?
BlackRock’s IBIT, with nearly $2.40 billion, or about 83% of the reported total.
-
Does the nearly 25% estimate mean every ETF shareholder is down that much?
No. It estimates Bitcoin prices on ETF net-deposit days, weighted by deposit size. Individual shareholders may have bought ETF shares at very different prices.
-
Does an investor selling ETF shares automatically make a fund sell Bitcoin?
No. Another investor may buy the shares. Fund holdings adjust through large-block creations and redemptions, and the reported flow total does not show how much Bitcoin was sold.